Not sure if Kyyote's 2nd sentence was a question or not, but I think it could have made a difference this year in particular.
What ever pitch Dimel is using, works. If Dimel took over the day after Kuglar bailed, he would have been able to establish a deeper rapport with kids & their families & would have had a shot at keeping the Top talent that was recruited. 3rd, he would have used an opposite pitch to get the kids that don't fit in his program to move to other schools so he can make room for more 3 & 4 stars (a la Floyd).
Dimel's history with recruiting proves his second year produces better talent (Houston).
This year it's all hypothetical, but clearly more options are available when more time is given.