I just did some poking around on our roster and on the transfer portal. If you assume players that have announced are leaving (plus Williams), as of right now we have two players on the team that are higher than 2 stars -- Bienemy and Kennedy. If Fisher still comes that makes three.
There's a LOT of players on the transfer portal Most are 2 star, but there's a reasonable number of 3-4 star players.
For reference, according to Verbal Commits, within CUSA we have the 3rd highest average star with 2.52 with ODU #1 and UAB #2. Obviously the star ranking is not great, but it suggests that we are all getting roughly the same talent. UNT near the bottom which shows the value of coaching skills. Within the WAC, no one is even close to NMSU at 2.87 which is higher than anyone in CUSA.
So using the weak rating system, even with our current talent level if CJG can make the most of them we should be at or near the top which we all felt. A relatively minor upgrade in talent from the portal and there is no reason we can't dominate CUSA like NMSU dominates the WAC. All assuming Golding is the coach we think he is.